Sandwiches in Fleming Island

Deli meats, chicken, and egg fillings anchor sandwiches at US 17 New York Deli in Fleming Island, FL, available for pickup.

Order online

Deli

Hot Pastrami Sandwich

$12.48+

Hot pastrami deli sandwich with customizable bread and condiments.

“I came here to service a oven for the deli after I finished the food they where cooking looked so fresh and smelled amazing that i decided to have lunch here. Melissa was extremely nice I ordered a hot pastrami on rye their way and let me tell you it was quite possibly the best sandwich I’ve ever eaten in the state of Florida. This place is AWESOME. And Melissa cares deeply about her customers. If I could give extra stars I would. Amazing place amazing service amazing SANDWICH.”

The New York Reuben's Sandwich

$10.99+

Corned beef, kraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island fill this deli sandwich.

“This restaurant is AMAZING and absolutely worth the drive from Macclenny, FL! The NY Reuben was OMG delicious! 😋 The ladies were so friendly and informative, and I love that everything is made in-house. And don’t forget to save room for your sweet tooth—ice cream, cheesecake, and key lime pie! 🍦🍰🥧 Highly recommend! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐”

Pastrami Special Sandwich

$15.60+

Pastrami, Swiss, coleslaw, and deli mustard fill rye bread.

“I highly recommend!! I went in when they were closing and they made me a sandwich anyway. It was a delicious sandwich!! Great service!! Go check them out!!”

Tuna Salad Sandwich

$11.99+

Tuna salad with lettuce on a choice of deli bread; cheese is optional.

“These Sandwiches are soooooo good! I love a local business that is as advertised. Will continue to support as I need to try one of everything. Cheers to SBO!”

Subs

Brooklyn Sub

$13.00+

Roast beef and sliced ham make a customizable 8- or 12-inch sub.

“Wow, Had the best pastrami sandwich, coming back for the Ruben looks delicious. Just found out they have Matzo Ball soups made in house. Got say I was there the staff nice and friendly. This is their second day. We finally got the much needed Deli. Definitely going to be a regular.”

Ultimate Spicy Italian Sub

$13.52+

Ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, and hot capicola fill this customizable sub.

“Great new place to eat! Very comprehensive menu with lots of options. Had the Ultimate Spicy Italian sub, which was excellent.”

Ultimate Roast Beef Sub

$13.52+

Premium roast beef comes on a sub with your choice of cheese.

“We visited US17 NY Deli a few days ago for lunch and WOW what a sandwich!!! I had the roast beef sub and it was delicious. The roast beef was sliced perfectly and the taste was on point!! Staff was great and extremely welcoming. They have a great menu with plenty to choose from. 1000% recommend and you can't go wrong when a fireman recommends it.”

Wall Street Sub

$13.00+

Pastrami, Swiss cheese, and deli mustard make this hot sub.

“I am visiting in town and was looking for a good lunch place. I asked around and I was told go to US-17 NY Deli. I went for lunch around 12ish, my food came out pretty quickly. My sandwich had more meat that I expected, I ended up having left overs. The prices were great for the amount of meat you get. It was so good I think I'll go back again.”

Cheesesteak

Philly Cheesesteak

$14.56+

Beef with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, and chosen cheese.

“Excellent Philly cheese steak. Love to support the family business!”

South Street Philly Cheesesteak

$12.48+

A beef cheesesteak with grilled onions and Cheese Whiz.

“Stop by for lunch today. Actually a sub place actually will put some meat on one of the sandwiches. Great food will be back”

Chicken Philly Cheesesteak

$14.56+

Chicken cheesesteak with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms; choose cheese.

Cheesesteak El Diablo

$12.48+

Beef, pepper jack, onions, jalapeños, banana peppers, and hot sauce.

Cuban Sandwiches

Classic Cuban Sandwich

$11.44+

Ham, mojo pork, Swiss, pickles, and mustard fill Cuban bread.

“This was my first time visiting the deli. My sandwich was really fresh and flavorful.”

Cuban American Pulled Deli Pork Sandwich

$11.44+

Pork with barbecue sauce, Swiss, coleslaw, and pickles on a kaiser roll.

Grinders

Grilled Chicken Parmesan Grinder

$13.00+

Grilled chicken with marinara, provolone, and Parmesan fills this grinder.

Pizza Grinder

$13.00+

Pepperoni, mozzarella, and marinara fill this hot grinder sandwich.

Toasted Paninis

Chicken Pesto Panini

$11.44+

Ciabatta holds grilled chicken, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and pesto mayo.

“The sandwiches here are amazing so are the staff❤️ will definitely be back”

Turkey Caesar Panini

$11.44

Turkey, Swiss, lettuce, onion, and Caesar dressing in a panini.

“Friendly and professional staff. Sandwiches and wraps were quite thick and absolutely delicious. We love this place.”

Pepper Jack Chicken Panini

$11.44

Grilled chicken and Pepper Jack with lettuce, tomato, and chipotle mayo.

Caprese Panini

$11.44

Toasted ciabatta holds mozzarella, tomato, pesto, and balsamic reduction.

Chicken

Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich

$13.52

Breaded chicken with hot sauce, pickles, and coleslaw on a kaiser roll.

“Great New addition to the island from scooped ice cream to delicious very meaty sandwiches. We can't wait to try the soups.”

Crispy Chicken Deluxe Sandwich

$11.44

Breaded chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a kaiser roll.

Spicy Chicken Deluxe Sandwich

$11.44

Breaded chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, and hot sauce on a kaiser roll.

California Avocado Chicken Club Sandwich

$15.60

Breaded chicken, avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on a kaiser roll.

Breakfast

8" Jaguar Breakfast Sub

$14.56

Egg patties, sausage patties, and bacon fill an 8-inch breakfast sub.

“High quality meats & cheeses in their subs. I added pickles and banana peppers to mine, and every single bite had pickles and banana peppers. My girlfriend's Rueben fix was very well taken care of. Really good pizza slice, too. Super friendly staff. We will be back for milkshakes & ice cream!”

Egg & Cheese with 2 Eggs

$9.06+

Two eggs and your chosen cheese come on a selected bread.

Breakfast Sandwiches with 1 Egg

$7.24+

One-egg breakfast sandwich with a choice of bread and optional meat.

12" Jaguar Breakfast Sub

$18.72

12-inch breakfast sub with egg, sausage, or bacon patties and cheese.

From the Kitchen at US 17 New York Deli

US 17 New York Deli serves sandwiches ranging from rye-bread deli stacks to chicken on kaiser rolls and egg-filled breakfast subs. You'll also find cheesesteaks with grilled onions and mushrooms.

Wall Street Sub pairs pastrami with Swiss and deli mustard. Brooklyn Sub has sliced roast beef and ham. Caprese Panini layers pesto, mozzarella, tomato, and balsamic reduction on ciabatta.

Visit US 17 New York Deli in Fleming Island, FL for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Roast Beef Grinder comes with melted provolone and au jus on the side, with 8-inch and 12-inch sizes available.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Philly Cheesesteak — This cheesesteak has beef with grilled onions, bell peppers, and mushrooms; choose from several cheeses, including provolone, or no cheese.
Breakfast Sandwiches with 1 Egg — Build a one-egg breakfast sandwich on a selected bagel, croissant, roll, or bread, with meat and extra cheese available optionally.
Trump Tower Sub — This sub combines pastrami and corned beef with Swiss and deli mustard; hot or cold service and toast levels are customizable.
Hot Pastrami Sandwich — The hot pastrami sandwich can be customized with a bread choice and condiments; select a regular or New York size.
The New York Reuben's Sandwich — The Reuben-style sandwich combines corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island; choose bread and a toast level to customize it.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Fleming Island area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.