Brooklyn Sub
$13.00+
Sub with sliced roast beef and ham, plus a required cheese choice.
“These Sandwiches are soooooo good! I love a local business that is as advertised. Will continue to support as I need to try one of everything. Cheers to SBO!”
Sandwiches to Try
Chicken Pesto Panini
$11.44+
Toasted panini with chicken, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and pesto mayo.
“Friendly and professional staff. Sandwiches and wraps were quite thick and absolutely delicious. We love this place.”
Classic Cuban Sandwich
$11.44+
Cuban sandwich with ham, mojo pork, Swiss, pickles, and yellow mustard.
“Stop by for lunch today. Actually a sub place actually will put some meat on one of the sandwiches. Great food will be back”
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
$12.48+
Hot pastrami fills rye bread with spicy deli mustard.
“Only place i could find hot pastrami in town and it does not disapoint”
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
$13.52
Breaded chicken with hot sauce, pickles, and coleslaw on a Kaiser roll.
“High quality meats & cheeses in their subs. I added pickles and banana peppers to mine, and every single bite had pickles and banana peppers. My girlfriend's Rueben fix was very well taken care of. Really good pizza slice, too. Super friendly staff. We will be back for milkshakes & ice cream!”
Pastrami Special Sandwich
$15.60+
Pastrami sandwich with Swiss, coleslaw, and deli mustard on rye.
“Best pastrami around.”
The New York Reuben's Sandwich
$10.99+
Corned beef, kraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island sit on grilled rye bread.
“Wife and I split a NY Reuben today. Impressed with the quality and taste of the food. The pastrami and corned beef were warm and thinly sliced. Service was great and the restaurant was clean. We were told that they will be doing milkshakes soon! Looking forward to eating here again!”
Tuna Salad Sandwich
$11.99+
Tuna salad sandwich with lettuce and optional cheese and vegetables.
“First visit was for the New York, New York size, and it was absolutely delicious! It’s a small deli that packs a huge punch of flavor. I highly recommend coming in for some amazing food and taste of New York right here on Fleming Island.”
Turkey Caesar Panini
$11.44
Toasted ciabatta holds turkey, Swiss, lettuce, onion, and Caesar dressing.
“Love this place. The food is fantastic. The Caesar dressing is something to experience.”
Ultimate Club Sub
$13.52+
Roast turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo fill a cold sub.
“The sandwiches here are amazing so are the staff❤️ will definitely be back”
Ultimate Roast Beef Sub
$13.52+
A roast beef sub with a required cheese choice and optional toppings.
“We visited US17 NY Deli a few days ago for lunch and WOW what a sandwich!!! I had the roast beef sub and it was delicious. The roast beef was sliced perfectly and the taste was on point!! Staff was great and extremely welcoming. They have a great menu with plenty to choose from. 1000% recommend and you can't go wrong when a fireman recommends it.”
Ultimate Spicy Italian Sub
$13.52+
Ham, salami, pepperoni, and hot capicola fill a sub with required cheese.
“Great new place to eat! Very comprehensive menu with lots of options. Had the Ultimate Spicy Italian sub, which was excellent.”
Wall Street Sub
$13.00+
Pastrami sub with Swiss cheese and deli mustard.
“This was my first time visiting the deli. My sandwich was really fresh and flavorful.”
Chicken Gyro
$13.52
Toasted pita with chicken, feta, tomato, lettuce, onion, and tzatziki.
Crispy Chicken Deluxe Sandwich
$11.44
Breaded chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, mayo on a kaiser roll.
Cuban American Pulled Deli Pork Sandwich
$11.44+
Mojo pork with BBQ sauce, Swiss, coleslaw, and pickles on a kaiser roll.
Deli Turkey Sandwich
$11.44+
Turkey, lettuce, and chosen cheese fill a customizable deli sandwich.
Grilled Chicken Parmesan Grinder
$13.00+
Grilled chicken, marinara, provolone, and Parmesan fill this grinder.
Pepper Jack Chicken Panini
$11.44
Grilled chicken panini has Pepper Jack, tomato, lettuce and chipotle mayo.
Pizza Grinder
$13.00+
A sandwich filled with pepperoni, melted mozzarella, and marinara sauce.
Sausage & Peppers Grinder
$13.00+
Italian sausage, sweet peppers, and provolone fill a grinder.
Turkey Special Sandwich
$15.60+
Turkey with Swiss, coleslaw, and Thousand Island on wheat bread.
Ultimate Egg Salad Sub
$13.52+
Egg salad fills a sub with a required cheese choice and optional toppings.
Ultimate Ham Sub
$12.48+
Ham fills a sub with a required cheese choice and optional toppings.
Ultimate Tuna Salad Sub
$13.52+
Tuna salad fills a sub with a required cheese choice and optional toppings.
Beef & Lamb Gyro
$13.52
Toasted pita with seasoned beef and lamb, feta, vegetables, and tzatziki.
“Easy to order online for 6 people. Everyone thought their sandwiches were very good.... quality & quantity of meat were excellent.”
BLT Sandwich
$10.40+
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato are served together in a customizable sandwich.
“I enjoyed my BLT & will be back for another. Very nice place, clean & welcoming atmosphere.”
Chicken Cordon Bleu Grinder
$14.00+
Grinder with breaded chicken, ham, bacon, Swiss cheese, and honey mustard.
“I am visiting in town and was looking for a good lunch place. I asked around and I was told go to US-17 NY Deli. I went for lunch around 12ish, my food came out pretty quickly. My sandwich had more meat that I expected, I ended up having left overs. The prices were great for the amount of meat you get. It was so good I think I'll go back again.”
Corned Beef Ruben Sandwich
$10.99+
Pastrami with kraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island comes on grilled rye bread.
“Must try this place out, we got a bagel sandwich, BLT and Reuben sandwiches that was amazing. Great service°°”
Deli Liverwurst & Onion Sandwich
$10.40+
Smooth liver sausage and raw onions fill a cold deli sandwich.
“Today we had the best chicken noodle soup ever, Grilled chicken in the soup and the flavor was amazing!!! I added a piece of chocolate cream pie, was delicious, not too sweet! My husband ate a liverwurst sandwich and loved it!”
Deli Meat Plate 3 Meat
$19.76
Three quarter-pound meat servings with Swiss, mustard, pickle, and slaw.
“That deli meat that deli meat be so good! The staff does some serious work! Thank you for what you do for the community!”
Deli Roast Beef Sandwich
$10.99+
Roast beef and lettuce fill a customizable deli sandwich.
“Best Roast Beef I have ever eaten. So fresh and tender makes my mouth water for more”
Deluxe Cuban Sandwich
$12.48+
Ham, pork, Swiss, pickles, mustard, mayo, lettuce, and tomato are layered.
“We have found our deli! I had the Cuban deluxe and my husband had the Reuben. My sandwich was flavorful and the hubby says his Reuben was the best he has had in the greater JAX area. I also had the French Onion soup…it was rich and delicious. Fantastic value for the portion size. Staff was friendly and the restaurant is very clean. We will be back!”
Egg Salad Sandwich
$11.44+
Egg salad sandwich with lettuce and tomato, plus optional cheese.
“I highly recommend!! I went in when they were closing and they made me a sandwich anyway. It was a delicious sandwich!! Great service!! Go check them out!!”
Empire State Sub
$13.00+
Sub with roast beef, turkey, and ham, plus a required cheese choice.
“Great deli to grab a delicious sandwich. Love having a local sandwich shop on fleming island. Please come out and support them!”
Long Island Sub
$13.00+
Turkey and ham fill a customizable sub with optional cheese and toppings.
“I tried the US 17 NY Deli today for the first time and was impressed. The Long Island was so delicious! I am a pickle lover and their pickles were great. The service with a smile will bring me back.”
New York New York Sandwich
$12.48+
Pastrami and corned beef come on rye with deli mustard.
“The corned beef on rye reminds me of home. So yummy”
New York New York Special Sandwich
$15.60+
Corned beef and pastrami sandwich with Swiss, coleslaw, mustard, and rye.
“The NY NY sandwich (pastrami and corned beef) is fantastic!! They’re quick, the food is great, and the folks are friendly. I’m definitely coming back.”
Pastrami Reuben Sandwich
$10.99+
Pastrami, sauerkraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island fill grilled rye.
“I got the pastrami reuben NY size ,and it was fantastic. The flavor of the pastrami was heavenly. I would come back again just for that sandwich. Next time I think I’ll get a pastrami and corned beef reuben. They also sell 6 pack of bagels from Just Bagels in NYC. I’m going to have to come back for those bagels to bring home. I forgot to get my Dr Browns soda dang it!!! Ohh well next time I’ll remember.”
Roast Beef Grinder
$13.00+
Roast beef and melted provolone come with au jus served on the side.
“The wife and I wanted to try someplace new. We read some reviews and decided to give them a try. This place did not disappoint! I got the NY pastrami sandwich and she got the roast beef grinder. Both were delicious! There was plenty of stuff on the menu that looked really good. We will be back to try more of the menu.”
Rudy Reuben Sub
$13.00+
Corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island on a sub.
“We both had different breads for the same sandwich, Reubens. Excellent quality Pastrami & Corned Beef with delicious fresh melted cheese and Kraut. The pickles were fantastic and the side of Italian Pasta salad was dressed perfectly with meats and olives. Our cashier was very warm and kind, and back of house nailed it with the sandwiches. We will be back with the family next, truly a hidden gem in the Fleming Island area!”
Turkey Reuben Sandwich
$10.99+
Roast turkey, kraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island fill grilled rye bread.
“Second time coming... They have hit their groove! The food and service is great! We had the Reuben and a Greek Salad. Highly recommend both!”
Ultimate Chicken Salad Sub
$13.52+
Chicken salad fills a cold sub with required cheese and optional toppings.
“Great food and excellent service! The food was all fresh and made to order which was such a nice change of pace. That was some of the best chicken salad I've ever had, we will definitely be back!”
Ultimate Italian Sub
$13.52+
Ham, Genoa salami, and pepperoni fill a cold sub with cheese.
“Had the Ultimate italian, toasted. Great food. Atmosphere was quiet and peaceful. Food was ready in not time at all. Great lunch spot.”
California Avocado Chicken Club Sandwich
$15.60
A breaded chicken sandwich with avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Caprese Panini
$11.44
Pesto, mozzarella, tomato, and balsamic reduction fill toasted ciabatta.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$11.99+
Chicken salad fills a sandwich with optional cheese and vegetable toppings.
Corned Beef Special Sandwich
$15.60+
Corned beef, Swiss, mustard, and coleslaw stack on rye bread.
Crispy Chicken Club Sandwich
$13.52
Breaded chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo come on a kaiser roll.
Deli Club Cabby Sandwich
$12.48+
Turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo make this club sandwich.
Deli Ham Sandwich
$11.44+
Ham, lettuce, tomato, and chosen cheese fill a customizable deli sandwich.
Deli Meat Plate 2 Meat
$15.60
Two quarter-pound deli meats with cheese, mustard, pickle, and slaw.
Egg Plant Parmesan Grinder
$13.00+
Eggplant grinder with marinara, Parmesan, melted provolone, and au jus.
Grilled Buffalo Chicken Grinder
$13.00+
Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, and provolone fill an 8- or 12-inch sub.
Grilled Chicken Bacon Ranch Grinder
$14.00+
Grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar, ranch, lettuce, and tomato in a grinder.
Hot Corned Beef Sandwich
$12.48+
Hot corned beef comes on rye bread with deli mustard and Swiss cheese.
Hot Ham Bacon Cheddar Grinder
$13.00+
A hot grinder with ham, bacon, cheddar, ranch, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Hot Turkey Bacon Ranch Grinder
$13.00+
Hot turkey, bacon, Cheddar, ranch, lettuce, and tomato fill a grinder.
Manhattan Sub
$13.00+
A sub filled with roast beef and turkey, with a required cheese choice.
Meatball Parmesan Grinder
$13.00+
Meatballs, marinara, provolone, and Parmesan fill an 8- or 12-inch sub.
Meatballs & Sausage Parmesan Grinder
$14.00+
This grinder has meatballs, sausage, marinara, mozzarella, and Parmesan.
NY Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$9.25+
Grilled white bread filled with American, provolone, and cheddar cheeses.
Smokehouse Ham Panini
$11.44
Smoked ham, Pepper Jack, lettuce, tomato, and chipotle mayo fill ciabatta.
Spicy Chicken Deluxe Sandwich
$11.44
Breaded chicken with lettuce, tomato, and hot sauce comes on a kaiser roll.
The Harlem Grinder
$13.00+
Beef patty, American cheese, onions, lettuce, and tomato fill a grinder.
Times Square Sub
$13.00+
A deli sub filled with corned beef, Swiss cheese, and deli mustard.
Trump Tower Sub
$13.00+
Pastrami, corned beef, Swiss, and deli mustard fill this hot sub.
Ultimate BLT Sub
$10.44+
A bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and cheese sub on white bread.
Ultimate Pepperoni Sub
$12.48+
Pepperoni and a required cheese choice form a customizable cold sub.
Ultimate Salami Sub
$12.48+
Cold salami sub with your choice of cheese and an 8- or 12-inch size.
Ultimate Turkey Sub
$12.48+
Roasted turkey breast fills a sub with cheese and optional toppings.
Ultimate Veggie Sub
$10.40+
A vegetable sub includes a required cheese choice and optional toppings.
