Desserts in Fleming Island

A sweet finish to your meal awaits with desserts at US 17 New York Deli in Fleming Island, FL, available to order for pickup.

Order online

Desserts to Try

Homemade Cookies

Choose a cookie flavor, including chocolate chip, red velvet, or s'mores.

“Order to everything bagel egg cheese and bacon sandwich added avocado the bread fantastic you can tell his homemade service impeccable lovely lady at the register welcoming, is very helpful food hot and delicious, the cookies are freshly baked They cost 5 dollars cause they are the size of a small dinner plate. 😀 worth it Reminds me of home will be back”

Cannoli's

$3.85

Crisp pastry shells hold sweetened ricotta cream in this Italian dessert.

Chocolate Mousse Cake

$6.24

Chocolate mousse cake brings airy chocolate mousse in cake form.

New York Cheesecake Slice

$6.24

A New York-style cheesecake slice can include optional strawberry glaze.

Key Lime Pie

$6.24

Tangy lime custard baked in a pie crust makes this citrus dessert.

“This restaurant is AMAZING and absolutely worth the drive from Macclenny, FL! The NY Reuben was OMG delicious! 😋 The ladies were so friendly and informative, and I love that everything is made in-house. And don’t forget to save room for your sweet tooth—ice cream, cheesecake, and key lime pie! 🍦🍰🥧 Highly recommend! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐”

Cookie & Drink

$5.49+

Choose a cookie and soda or tea, with regular or jumbo sizing.

New York Black & White Cookies

$4.16

A soft cookie with half vanilla icing and half chocolate icing.

Made with Care at US 17 New York Deli

US 17 New York Deli serves desserts in cookie, pie and cake formats. You can finish with cannoli, choose a chocolate mousse cake or enjoy the New York style of black-and-white cookies.

Homemade Cookies come in apple caramel crisp and red velvet flavors. You can add strawberry glaze to Key Lime Pie and New York Cheesecake Slice for a fruit-flavored topping on either dessert.

In Fleming Island, FL, you can order for pickup, dine-in and delivery. Cookie & Drink offers regular or jumbo sizes, with choices such as a chocolate chip cookie paired with pink lemonade.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular desserts options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Cannoli's — Cannoli are crisp, tube-shaped pastry shells filled with sweetened ricotta cream, offering a creamy center and delicate shell.
New York Black & White Cookies — This New York-style cookie has a soft, cake-like texture and the classic split topping of vanilla and chocolate icing.
Chocolate Mousse Cake — Chocolate mousse cake is a dessert, and strawberry glaze can be added as an optional customization.
Homemade Cookies — Select one of the listed cookie flavors, such as chocolate chip, M&M, red velvet, Reese’s peanut butter, or s'mores.
Key Lime Pie — This classic pie features a tangy key lime custard filling in a crust; strawberry glaze is available as an optional topping.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for desserts throughout the Fleming Island area. Order your desserts online for convenient pickup or delivery.