Desserts in Fleming Island

Satisfy your sweet tooth with desserts at US 17 New York Deli in Fleming Island, FL, available for convenient pickup today.

Order online

From the Kitchen at US 17 New York Deli

US 17 New York Deli in Fleming Island, FL offers a satisfying desserts menu with classic and indulgent options sure to please any sweet tooth.

Choose from crowd-pleasing favorites like New York Cheesecake Slice, Chocolate Mousse Cake, Key Lime Pie, Cannoli's, Homemade Cookies, and New York Black & White Cookies.

Visit US 17 New York Deli in Fleming Island, FL to enjoy desserts your way — dine-in, pickup, or delivery makes it easy to treat yourself anytime.

Desserts to Try

Homemade Cookies

$3.64

Choose one homemade cookie in flavors like chocolate chip or sugar.

“Order to everything bagel egg cheese and bacon sandwich added avocado the bread fantastic you can tell his homemade service impeccable lovely lady at the register welcoming, is very helpful food hot and delicious, the cookies are freshly baked They cost 5 dollars cause they are the size of a small dinner plate. 😀 worth it Reminds me of home will be back”

Cannoli's

$3.85

Pastry shells hold sweet ricotta filling in this Italian dessert.

Chocolate Mousse Cake

$6.24

Chocolate mousse forms the creamy layer in this chocolate cake dessert.

New York Cheesecake Slice

$6.24

New York-style cheesecake comes as a slice with optional strawberry glaze.

Cookie & Drink

$5.49+

A cookie and a selected soda or tea flavor make this combo.

“This restaurant is AMAZING and absolutely worth the drive from Macclenny, FL! The NY Reuben was OMG delicious! 😋 The ladies were so friendly and informative, and I love that everything is made in-house. And don’t forget to save room for your sweet tooth—ice cream, cheesecake, and key lime pie! 🍦🍰🥧 Highly recommend! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐”

Key Lime Pie

$6.24

Key lime pie features tangy, creamy lime custard in a baked crust.

New York Black & White Cookies

$4.16

A soft cookie is topped with vanilla and chocolate icing.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular desserts options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Cannoli's — Cannoli are crisp pastry tubes filled with sweet ricotta cream, offering a classic Italian dessert with a crunchy shell.
Chocolate Mousse Cake — This dessert is a chocolate cake with a soft mousse layer and optional strawberry glaze.
New York Cheesecake Slice — This dessert is a single cheesecake slice; strawberry glaze is available as an optional addition.
New York Black & White Cookies — This New York-style cookie has a soft base with contrasting vanilla and chocolate icing on top.
Homemade Cookies — Select one cookie flavor, including chocolate chip, sugar, red velvet, peanut butter, s'mores, or apple caramel crisp.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for desserts throughout the Fleming Island area. Order your desserts online for convenient pickup or delivery.