Pizza in Fleming Island

Cheese and pepperoni pizza comes in whole pies or slices at US 17 New York Deli in Fleming Island, FL, with pickup available.

Order online

Pizza to Try

Whole Cheese Pizza

Whole cheese pizza with optional meat or vegetable toppings.

Meatball & Green Pepper Pizza$26.80Whole cheese pizza topped with meatballs and green peppers for a savory, mildly sweet combination.
Italian Sausage & Mushroom Pizza$26.80Whole cheese pizza topped with Italian sausage and mushrooms for a savory, classic-style combination.
Bacon & Jalapeño Pizza$26.80Whole cheese pizza topped with bacon and jalapeño peppers for a savory pizza with a spicy kick.
Mushroom, Olive & Green Pepper Pizza$28.80Whole cheese pizza topped with mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, and onions for a vegetable option.

“I had such a great meal! The pizza is to die for and they have Red Bull infusions! Wild berries with mango syrup is my fave!”

Whole Pepperoni Pizza

A whole pepperoni pizza topped with cheese and tomato sauce.

Cheese Pizza Slice

$4.16

A slice of cheese pizza with tomato sauce and melted cheese.

“High quality meats & cheeses in their subs. I added pickles and banana peppers to mine, and every single bite had pickles and banana peppers. My girlfriend's Rueben fix was very well taken care of. Really good pizza slice, too. Super friendly staff. We will be back for milkshakes & ice cream!”

Pepperoni Pizza Slice

$5.20

A pizza slice topped with pepperoni, tomato sauce, and cheese.

A Taste of US 17 New York Deli

At US 17 New York Deli, pizza comes as whole pies or individual slices, with cheese and pepperoni styles. Whole pies can also include additional meat and vegetable toppings, plus extra cheese.

Whole Cheese Pizza has extra mozzarella as an option; Whole Pepperoni Pizza can include Italian sausage. Pair your Cheese Pizza Slice with a 4 oz cup of marinara or pesto on the side.

Visit US 17 New York Deli in Fleming Island, FL for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. For your Pepperoni Pizza Slice, add a 4 oz cup of ranch, blue cheese, or honey mustard dressing on the side.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular pizza options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Pepperoni Pizza Slice — This single slice has pepperoni over the familiar tomato sauce and cheese topping; optional dressings are served on the side.
Whole Pepperoni Pizza — This whole pizza has a classic tomato sauce and cheese base topped with pepperoni; extra meats, vegetables, and cheese are optional.
Whole Cheese Pizza — The whole pizza is cheese-topped, with meat, vegetable, and extra mozzarella or feta additions available separately.
Cheese Pizza Slice — A single slice features a classic tomato sauce and cheese topping; optional dressings can be ordered on the side.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for pizza throughout the Fleming Island area. Order your pizza online for convenient pickup or delivery.